TMBTMB
TMBTMB

Track, discover and find where to watch TV shows and movies.

Discover

  • Movies
  • TV Shows
  • Browse
  • Topics

Account

  • Watchlist
  • Watched
  • Ratings

Legal

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service

© 2026 Movie Browser. All rights reserved.

Data provided by TMDB

Home
Browse
Watchlist
backdrop
backdrop
logo
A 1919 feminist fairy godmother arrives with a fat bank account and zero patience for your nonsense.
TMDB
80

Erstwhile Susan (1919)

proto-feminist revenge fantasysilent era sassPennsylvania Dutch dramedy

Overview

Drama

Barnabetta Dreary's grim life of slaving for her Pennsylvania Dutch father Barnaby and her two brothers, is surprisingly changed when Barnaby marries Juliet Miller. Known as Erstwhile Susan, she becomes fond of Barnabetta, and because she retains control of her fortune, induces the other Drearys to relieve Barnabetta of some of her drudgery.

Flag of USUS
Content warning
economic liberation as personal freedomfound maternal bondsthe performance of domestic labor

Standout Aspects

Acting

Mary Alden's Susan: silent film side-eye that transcends time.

Production

Surprisingly detailed Pennsylvania Dutch sets for 1919.

Best for:Solo: Silent film curious? This one's actually accessible, not homework.·Rewatch: Spot how Susan weaponizes politeness like a dagger.
John S. Robertson

Director

John S. Robertson

ReleasedNov 16, 1919
Runtime1h
StatusReleased

Vibe

Pacesteady
Intensitymedium
Tonemixed
Feelmedium
Realart Pictures Corporation

Top Cast

Constance Binney

Constance Binney

Barnabetta Dreary

Jere Austin

Jere Austin

David Jordan

Alfred Hickman

Alfred Hickman

Dr. Edgar Barrett

Mary Alden

Mary Alden

Erstwhile Susan

Anders Randolf

Anders Randolf

Barnaby Dreary

Georges Renavent

Georges Renavent

Emanual Dreary

Bradley Barker

Bradley Barker

Jacob Dreary

Ask about Erstwhile Susan

Opens AI chat

Deep Dive

Trivia, insights & behind the scenes

Cultural

Based on a 1914 stage play by Marian DeForest, one of the few successful female playwrights of the era—Hollywood was already mining Broadway's women writers.

Insight

Constance Binney was a huge star who quit acting in 1923 to marry a millionaire—life imitating Susan's plot, but backwards.

Recommended

Eleanor the Great movie poster (2025)
6.9

Eleanor the Great

A Question of Faith movie poster (2017)
7.5

A Question of Faith

Return movie poster (2011)
6.4

Return

The Truth About Emanuel movie poster (2013)
6.0

The Truth About Emanuel

Reading Lolita in Tehran movie poster (2024)
7.3

Reading Lolita in Tehran

Mansfield Park movie poster (2007)
6.1

Mansfield Park

Jimmy P. movie poster (2013)
6.0

Jimmy P.

Waiting for Anya movie poster (2020)
6.3

Waiting for Anya

All Together Now movie poster (2020)
6.7

All Together Now

The Book of Daniel movie poster (2013)
7.0

The Book of Daniel

Woman of Straw movie poster (1964)
6.2

Woman of Straw

The Young Philadelphians movie poster (1959)
7.4

The Young Philadelphians

Here movie poster (2024)
6.5

Here

Won't Back Down movie poster (2012)
6.1

Won't Back Down

Seeds of Yesterday movie poster (2015)
6.4

Seeds of Yesterday