When a cosmic event turns Emma's dog and cat into two perfect guys, Emma reconsiders her outlook on dating, hilariously works out her trust issues, and ultimately learns to love herself.
Acting
Kate Micucci's nervous energy carries every scene.
Writing
Dialogue nails the absurd without winking too hard.
Director
Finn Taylor
Trivia, insights & behind the scenes
Kate Micucci is half of Garfunkel and Oates; her musical comedy background explains Emma's specific awkward rhythm.
The film quietly subverts the 'magical boyfriend' trope by making the magic literal—and then making Emma reject both magical options.
US
