TMBTMB
TMBTMB

Track, discover and find where to watch TV shows and movies.

Discover

  • Movies
  • TV Shows
  • Browse
  • Topics

Account

  • Watchlist
  • Watched
  • Ratings

Legal

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service

© 2026 Movie Browser. All rights reserved.

Data provided by TMDB

Home
Browse
Watchlist
backdrop
backdrop
logo
The only swashbuckler where the hero has TWO identities and zero moral clarity.
TMDB
58
IMDb
57
Watch(GB)

Caribbean (1952)

sweaty period dramaidentity crisis cosplaycolonial karma

Overview

Adventure

Francis Barclay, a former member of the British Admiralty, who was captured in the early 1700s, and sold into slavery, by Andrew McAllister, and forced into piracy, enlists the aid of Dick Lindsay, to help him invade MacAllister's fortified island. The latter falls in love with MacAllister's daughter,Christine.

Flag of USUS
Content warning
pirate18th century
revenge vs. redemptioncolonial exploitationperformance of identitylove across enemy lines

Standout Aspects

Acting

John Payne playing twins with wildly different vibes.

Production

Gloriously fake Caribbean sets that scream '1952 backlot.'

Best for:Solo: Rainy afternoon when you need pirates but make it complicated.·Background: Fold laundry to sword fights and betrayal monologues.
Heads up:Violence: Sword fights, slavery backstory, colonial cruelty treated lightly.
Edward Ludwig

Director

Edward Ludwig

ReleasedSep 1, 1952
Runtime1h 31m
StatusReleased

Vibe

Pacesteady
Intensitymedium
Tonemixed
Feelmedium
Revenue$1
Paramount Pictures
Pine-Thomas Productions

Top Cast

John Payne

John Payne

Dick Lindsay / Robert McAllister

Arlene Dahl

Arlene Dahl

Christine Barclay McAllister

Cedric Hardwicke

Cedric Hardwicke

Captain Francis Barclay

Francis L. Sullivan

Francis L. Sullivan

Andrew McAllister

Willard Parker

Willard Parker

Shively

Dennis Hoey

Dennis Hoey

Burford

Clarence Muse

Clarence Muse

Quashy

William Pullen

William Pullen

Robert McAllister

Walter Reed

Walter Reed

Evans

John Hart

John Hart

Stuart

Woody Strode

Woody Strode

Esau

Ask about Caribbean

Opens AI chat

Deep Dive

Trivia, insights & behind the scenes

Trivia

John Payne plays both Lindsay and Robert McAllister, though the marketing barely hinted at the twin twist to preserve the surprise.

Cultural

This was Arlene Dahl's 'exotic' phase—she plays 'half-Spanish' despite being Minnesota Norwegian, because 1952.

Gallery

Recommended

Swashbuckler movie poster (1976)
6.1

Swashbuckler

Anne of the Indies movie poster (1951)
6.4

Anne of the Indies

The Black Pirate movie poster (1926)
6.7

The Black Pirate

Nate and Hayes movie poster (1983)
6.1

Nate and Hayes

Treasure Island movie poster (1972)
5.9

Treasure Island

The Crimson Pirate movie poster (1952)
7.0

The Crimson Pirate

Treasure Island movie poster (1950)
6.6

Treasure Island

Against All Flags movie poster (1952)
6.1

Against All Flags

Cutthroat Island movie poster (1995)
5.8

Cutthroat Island

Treasure Island movie poster (1934)
6.5

Treasure Island

Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl movie poster (2003)
7.8

Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl

Jamaica Inn movie poster (1939)
6.1

Jamaica Inn

Captain Blood movie poster (1935)
7.2

Captain Blood

The Black Swan movie poster (1942)
6.5

The Black Swan

Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End movie poster (2007)
7.3

Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End

More Like This

Captain Blood movie poster (1935)
7.2

Captain Blood

Tales of the Black Freighter movie poster (2009)
6.6

Tales of the Black Freighter

The Boy and the Pirates movie poster (1960)
5.7

The Boy and the Pirates

Mysterious Island movie poster (1961)
6.6

Mysterious Island

Captain Clegg movie poster (1962)
6.3

Captain Clegg

Barbary Pirate movie poster (1949)
6.5

Barbary Pirate

Hornblower: The Even Chance movie poster (1998)
7.5

Hornblower: The Even Chance

One Piece: The Movie movie poster (2000)
7.1

One Piece: The Movie

Treasure Island movie poster (1990)
6.6

Treasure Island

The Devil-Ship Pirates movie poster (1964)
5.7

The Devil-Ship Pirates

The Princess and the Pirate movie poster (1944)
6.9

The Princess and the Pirate

Casanova movie poster (2005)
6.4

Casanova

Project A movie poster (1983)
7.2

Project A

Treasure Island movie poster (1972)
5.9

Treasure Island

The Scarlet Pimpernel movie poster (1934)
7.0

The Scarlet Pimpernel